2× Stanley Cup ★ 3× GM of the Year 4 Finals 20 playoff appearances
| Season | Team | GP | W | L | OT | PTS | Finish | Playoffs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NSHL25 | TOR |
80 | 44 | 28 | 8 | 130 | 9 of 28 | Lost in Round 1 |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
78 | 39 | 32 | 7 | 113 | 18 of 24 | Missed playoffs |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
78 | 34 | 34 | 10 | 106 | 17 of 24 | Missed playoffs |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
78 | 30 | 35 | 13 | 95 | 22 of 24 | Missed playoffs |
| NSHL21 | TOR |
78 | 38 | 30 | 10 | 117 | 14 of 24 | Lost in Round 1 |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
82 | 44 | 28 | 10 | 128 | 7 of 22 | Lost in Round 2 |
| NSHL19 | TOR |
82 | 39 | 33 | 10 | 116 | 15 of 22 | Lost in Wild Card |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
80 | 38 | 29 | 13 | 121 | 12 of 20 | Missed playoffs |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
80 | 44 | 27 | 9 | 128 | 6 of 20 | Lost in First Round |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
80 | 42 | 30 | 8 | 122 | 9 of 20 | Lost in First Round |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
80 | 42 | 31 | 7 | 129 | 5 of 20 | Lost in First Round |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
80 | 46 | 27 | 7 | 132 | 3 of 20 | Lost in Second Round |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
80 | 45 | 31 | 4 | 132 | 5 of 21 | Lost in Second Round |
| NSHL12 | TOR |
80 | 58 | 16 | 6 | 169 | 1 of 21 | Won Stanley Cup GMOTY |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
78 | 51 | 24 | 3 | 152 | 1 of 24 | Lost in Final GMOTY |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
78 | 45 | 26 | 7 | 135 | 5 of 24 | Lost in Conference Final |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
78 | 40 | 28 | 10 | 122 | 10 of 24 | Lost in First Round |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
74 | 41 | 27 | 6 | 122 | 8 of 24 | Lost in Second Round |
| NSHL7 | TOR |
60 | 33 | 23 | 4 | 99 | 7 of 24 | Lost in Second Round |
| NSHL6 | TOR |
74 | 42 | 26 | 11 | 95 | 1 of 24 | Lost in Second Round |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
74 | 47 | 21 | 6 | 100 | 2 of 24 | Won Stanley Cup![]() |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
64 | 38 | 20 | 6 | 82 | 2 of 20 | Lost in Final |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
62 | 37 | 18 | 7 | 81 | 2 of 20 | Lost in Quarterfinal |
| NSHL2 | TOR |
63 | 41 | 16 | 6 | 88 | 1 of 20 | Lost in Semifinal |
| NSHL1 | TOR |
85 | 53 | 27 | 5 | 111 | 1 of 16 | Not recorded GMOTY |
| Career | 1906 | 1051 | 667 | 193 | 2925 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round 1 | TOR |
HAM |
Lost | 1-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round 1 | TOR |
HAM |
Lost | 2-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round 1 | TOR |
TBL |
Won | 4-0 |
| Round 2 | TOR |
CHI |
Lost | 3-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wild Card | TOR |
BOS |
Won | 1-0 |
| Wild Card | TOR |
HAM |
Lost | 0-1 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
LAK |
Lost | 0-3 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
DET |
Lost | 2-3 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
CHI |
Lost | 0-2 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Second Round | TOR |
CHI |
Lost | 1-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
BOS |
Won | 2-1 |
| Second Round | TOR |
BUF |
Lost | 3-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Second Round | TOR |
NYR |
Won | 4-1 |
| Conference Final | TOR |
EDM |
Won | 4-1 |
| Stanley Cup Final | TOR |
CGY |
Won | 4-1 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
WSH |
Won | 4-1 |
| Second Round | TOR |
DET |
Won | 4-3 |
| Conference Final | TOR |
MTL |
Won | 4-3 |
| Stanley Cup Final | TOR |
MIN |
Lost | 2-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
DET |
Won | 4-3 |
| Second Round | TOR |
NYR |
Won | 4-0 |
| Conference Final | TOR |
PIT |
Lost | 2-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
BUF |
Lost | 3-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
PIT |
Won | 4-1 |
| Second Round | TOR |
BOS |
Lost | 2-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
CLE |
Won | 4-1 |
| Second Round | TOR |
BOS |
Lost | 0-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
NYR |
Won | 4-2 |
| Second Round | TOR |
HRT |
Lost | 3-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Round | TOR |
ATL |
Won | 4-1 |
| Second Round | TOR |
PHI |
Won | 4-1 |
| Conference Final | TOR |
OTT |
Won | 4-1 |
| Stanley Cup Final | TOR |
DET |
Won | 4-2 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quarterfinal | TOR |
NYI |
Won | 4-1 |
| Semifinal | TOR |
CBJ |
Won | 4-1 |
| Stanley Cup Final | TOR |
MIN |
Lost | 2-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quarterfinal | TOR |
CBJ |
Lost | 3-4 |
| Round | Team | Opponent | Result | Series |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quarterfinal | TOR |
DET |
Won | 4-0 |
| Semifinal | TOR |
LA |
Lost | 3-4 |
| Draft | Team | Round | Pick | Player | Pos |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| NSHL25 | TOR |
1 | 9 | Jackson Smith | D |
| NSHL25 | TOR |
2 | 37 | Maxim Shabanov via ANA | F |
| NSHL25 | TOR |
2 | 39 | Jack Murtagh via OTT | F |
| NSHL25 | TOR |
4 | 113 | Artur Akhtyamov via BOS | G |
| NSHL25 | TOR |
5 | 124 | Quinn Hutson via OTT | F |
| NSHL25 | TOR |
7 | 186 | Vyacheslav Peksa via DET | G |
| NSHL25 | TOR |
7 | 198 | Isak Posch via CBJ | G |
| NSHL25 | TOR |
7 | 199 | Cooper Gay via BOS | F |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
1 | 8 | Zayne Parekh | D |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
3 | 68 | Raoul Boilard via BOS | F |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
4 | 81 | Jacob Quillan | F |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
4 | 86 | Ben Steeves via COL | F |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
5 | 110 | Charles-Alexis Legault via COL | D |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
6 | 134 | Cooper Black via MTL | G |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
6 | 135 | Victor Ostman via COL | G |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
6 | 140 | Ryan Tverberg via TBL | F |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
7 | 153 | Dylan Duke via CAR | F |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
7 | 160 | Simon Forsmark via PIT | D |
| NSHL24 | TOR |
7 | 164 | Dylan Wendt via TBL | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
1 | 4 | Leo Carlsson | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
1 | 6 | David Reinbacher via NJD | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
1 | 7 | Zach Benson via NYI | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
1 | 8 | Axel Sandin Pellikka via VGK | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
1 | 22 | Adam Engstrom via MTL | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
1 | 23 | Andrew Cristall via LAK | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
2 | 26 | Mikhail Gulyayev via FLA | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
2 | 35 | Koehn Ziemmer via EDM | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
2 | 36 | Hunter Brzustewicz via COL | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
3 | 59 | Riley Heidt via SEA | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
3 | 63 | Luca Cagnoni via CAR | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
4 | 88 | Emil Pieniniemi via QUE | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
5 | 121 | Max Sasson via MTL | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
6 | 131 | Alexis Gendron via SEA | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
6 | 132 | Domenick Fensore via EDM | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
7 | 147 | Ryan McAllister via ANA | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
7 | 149 | Domenic DiVincentiis | G |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
7 | 157 | Will Zmolek via EDM | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
7 | 158 | Ondrej Pavel via COL | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
7 | 164 | Magnus Chrona via CBJ | G |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
7 | 165 | Max Crozier via TBL | D |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
7 | 167 | Parker Ford via PHI | F |
| NSHL23 | TOR |
7 | 168 | Carl Berglund via NYR | F |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
1 | 12 | Kevin Korchinski | D |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
1 | 24 | Owen Pickering via CHI | D |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
2 | 37 | Alex Steeves | F |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
2 | 38 | Maveric Lamoureux via DAL | D |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
2 | 46 | Francesco Arcuri via VGK | F |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
3 | 52 | Mattias Havelid via LAK | D |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
3 | 63 | Jani Nyman via DAL | F |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
4 | 96 | Arvid Soderblom via HAM | G |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
5 | 100 | Kasper Kulonummi via CBJ | D |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
5 | 101 | Liam Dower Nilsson via CAR | F |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
5 | 105 | Nicholas Moldenhauer via FLA | F |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
5 | 111 | Bryce McConnell-Barker via DET | F |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
5 | 115 | Kirill Dolzhenkov via BOS | F |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
5 | 116 | Kasper Puutio via VGK | D |
| NSHL22 | TOR |
7 | 154 | Max Wanner via TBL | D |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
3 | 45 | Jack Rathbone via STL | D |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
3 | 48 | Egor Zamula via MIN | D |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
3 | 52 | Justus Annunen | G |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
3 | 55 | David Farrance via SJS | D |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
4 | 68 | Max Gildon via STL | D |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
4 | 86 | Noah Cates via FLA | F |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
6 | 115 | Valtteri Puustinen via MIN | F |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
6 | 118 | Stelio Mattheos via PHI | F |
| NSHL20 | TOR |
7 | 134 | Nikolai Kovalenko via PHI | F |
| NSHL19 | TOR |
3 | 48 | Austin Wagner via WPG | F |
| NSHL19 | TOR |
6 | 122 | Jeremy Davies | D |
| NSHL19 | TOR |
6 | 137 | Mikhail Abramov via CHI | F |
| NSHL19 | TOR |
6 | 138 | Sam Montembeault via NYR | G |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
1 | 12 | Jesper Bratt via LAK | F |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
1 | 14 | Andreas Johnsson via NYR | F |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
2 | 37 | Mason Appleton via QUE | F |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
3 | 42 | Ian Mitchell via VAN | D |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
3 | 45 | Luc Snuggerud via CAR | D |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
3 | 54 | Lucas Wallmark via BOS | F |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
4 | 62 | Axel Jonsson-Fjallby via VAN | F |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
4 | 70 | Dominik Kahun via CGY | F |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
4 | 75 | Andreas Borgman | D |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
5 | 100 | Wade Allison via MTL | F |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
6 | 102 | Devon Toews via VAN | F |
| NSHL18 | TOR |
6 | 111 | Dylan Samberg via PIT | D |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
1 | 2 | NOLAN PATRICK via FLA | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
1 | 11 | CALE MAKAR | D |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
1 | 12 | NICK SUZUKI via VAN | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
2 | 21 | JAKUB ZBORIL via HAM | D |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
2 | 33 | DEVIN SHORE via SJS | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
2 | 34 | JAKE MCCABE via VAN | D |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
3 | 45 | CAL FOOTE via QUE | D |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
3 | 50 | ALEX KERFOOT via DET | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
3 | 51 | MIKE VECCHIONE via SJS | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
3 | 52 | SPENCER FOO via VAN | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
4 | 57 | NIC PETAN via EDM | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
4 | 58 | Mike Matheson via CGY | D |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
4 | 66 | JOEL ARMIA via CHI | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
4 | 68 | CAL PETERSEN via DET | G |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
4 | 69 | JOSEPH WOLL via SJS | G |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
5 | 79 | OSKAR STEEN via HAM | F |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
5 | 85 | SLATER KOEKKOEK via CAR | D |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
5 | 94 | BRETT LERNOUT via ANA | D |
| NSHL17 | TOR |
6 | 117 | JEAN-SEBASTIEN DEA via PIT | F |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
1 | 7 | COLTON PARAYKO via VAN | D |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
1 | 19 | BRETT PESCE via QUE | D |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
2 | 31 | JOEL EDMUNDSON via PHI | D |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
3 | 42 | NIKITA ZAITSEV via SEA | D |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
3 | 49 | DARREN DIETZ via CHI | D |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
5 | 82 | STEPHEN MICHALEK via SEA | G |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
5 | 85 | RADOVAN BONDRA via VAN | F |
| NSHL16 | TOR |
5 | 96 | CHARLIE LINDGREN | G |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
1 | 1 | CONNOR MCDAVID via MTL | F |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
1 | 12 | CHRISTIAN DVORAK via CAR | F |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
2 | 23 | NIKITA NESTEROV via MTL | D |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
2 | 27 | MICHAEL PALIOTTA via BOS | D |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
2 | 35 | COLIN MILLER via NYR | D |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
2 | 39 | J-F BERUBE via WPG | G |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
3 | 58 | BEN CHIAROT via NSH | D |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
3 | 60 | ZACH TROTMAN via WPG | D |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
3 | 61 | ANDREW COPP via FLA | F |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
4 | 62 | MACKENZIE SKAPSKI via BUF | G |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
4 | 68 | ANTON FORSBERG via BOS | G |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
4 | 70 | LAURENT BROSSOIT via CHI | G |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
5 | 91 | TREVOR VAN RIEMSDYK via CHI | D |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
5 | 100 | COLE ULLY | F |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
5 | 102 | KAAPO KAHKONEN via FLA | G |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
6 | 111 | LINUS SODERSTROM via CHI | G |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
6 | 113 | BRANDON HALVERSON via EDM | G |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
6 | 118 | ROURKE CHARTIER via CAR | F |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
6 | 119 | VINCE HINOSTROZA via NSH | F |
| NSHL15 | TOR |
6 | 122 | VITEK VANECEK via FLA | G |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
1 | 4 | MIKAEL GRANLUND via NYR | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
1 | 9 | SAM BENNETT via BOS | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
1 | 10 | TOMAS TATAR via TBL | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
1 | 12 | NIKOLAJ EHLERS via CAR | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
1 | 17 | RYAN ELLIS via WSH | D |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
2 | 34 | CHRISTIAN FOLIN via CHI | D |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
3 | 42 | CONNOR CARRICK via MTL | D |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
3 | 47 | TIM ERIXON via WPG | D |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
3 | 49 | TAYLOR BECK via NSH | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
3 | 51 | JASON AKESON via BOS | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
3 | 59 | MAREK MAZANEC via DAL | G |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
5 | 96 | SAMI AITTOKALLIO via EDM | G |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
5 | 97 | DAN O'REGAN via CHI | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
5 | 100 | CONNOR HELLEBUYCK via BUF | G |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
5 | 101 | BRANDEN TROOCK via DAL | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
5 | 102 | MIKE MATHESON | D |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
6 | 105 | Michael McCarron via QUE | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
6 | 106 | KRISTERS GUDLEVSKIS via CGY | G |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
6 | 107 | JORDAN SUBBAN via PHI | D |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
6 | 122 | BRANDON KOZUN | F |
| NSHL14 | TOR |
6 | 123 | TYE MCGINN via DET | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
1 | 1 | Nathan MacKinnon via TBL | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
1 | 8 | Elias Lindholm via PIT | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
1 | 10 | Danny DeKeyser via LAK | D |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
1 | 19 | Hunter Shinkaruk via MIN | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
3 | 49 | Matt Tennyson via MTL | D |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
3 | 50 | Reid Boucher via DET | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
3 | 53 | Charles Hudon via DAL | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
3 | 60 | Nic Petan via PHI | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
3 | 61 | Sven Andrighetto via CGY | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
4 | 82 | Oskar Sundqvist via CGY | F |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
5 | 106 | Marcus Hogberg via ANA | G |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
5 | 107 | Zane Gothberg via COL | G |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
6 | 121 | Tyler Cuma via EDM | D |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
6 | 126 | Nicolas Deslauriers via CGY | D |
| NSHL13 | TOR |
6 | 128 | Thomas Hickey | D |
| NSHL12 | TOR |
1 | 8 | Carl Hagelin via LAK | F |
| NSHL12 | TOR |
1 | 9 | Morgan Rielly via WSH | D |
| NSHL12 | TOR |
1 | 21 | Luke Adam via MIN | F |
| NSHL12 | TOR |
2 | 22 | James Reimer via PIT | G |
| NSHL12 | TOR |
3 | 60 | Eddie Lack via CHI | G |
| NSHL12 | TOR |
4 | 75 | Alex Guptill via WPG | F |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
1 | 2 | Gabriel Landeskog via COL | F |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
2 | 45 | Nick Spaling via NYR | F |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
3 | 49 | Blake Geoffrion via MIN | F |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
3 | 68 | Alexander Avtsin | F |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
4 | 77 | Chris Tanev via COL | D |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
4 | 86 | Zac Rinaldo via DET | F |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
4 | 89 | Richard Bachman via PHI | G |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
4 | 90 | Jerry D'Amigo via MTL | F |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
5 | 101 | Harry Zolnierczyk via COL | F |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
5 | 104 | Roman Josi via BOS | D |
| NSHL11 | TOR |
5 | 108 | Max Reinhart via STL | F |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
1 | 17 | Derek Forbort via PHI | D |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
1 | 21 | Andrei Loktionov via BUF | F |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
1 | 23 | Sergei Bobrovsky via ANA | G |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
2 | 32 | Joacim Ericsson via CHI | G |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
2 | 47 | Tommy Wingels via STL | F |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
3 | 51 | Jussi Rynnas via OTT | G |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
3 | 72 | David Savard via LAK | D |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
5 | 102 | Andrew MacDonald via VAN | D |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
5 | 107 | Mats Zuccarello via TBL | F |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
5 | 109 | Brayden Irwin via NYR | F |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
5 | 110 | Kenny Ryan via EDM | F |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
5 | 113 | Eric Wellwood via SJS | F |
| NSHL10 | TOR |
5 | 116 | Oskars Bartulis via ANA | D |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
1 | 7 | Jonathan Quick via LAK | G |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
1 | 13 | Jonas Anhelov via COL | D |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
1 | 21 | Chris Butler via CGY | D |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
1 | 22 | Bobby Sanguinetti via BOS | D |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
1 | 23 | Ryan Ellis via ANA | D |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
2 | 30 | Brett Sonne via CBJ | F |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
3 | 52 | Darroll Powe via VAN | F |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
3 | 57 | Linus Omark via DAL | F |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
3 | 62 | Jamie McGinn via COL | F |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
3 | 65 | Mike Murphy via CGY | G |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
4 | 77 | Derek Stepan via LAK | F |
| NSHL9 | TOR |
4 | 88 | Peter Regin via NJD | F |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
1 | 23 | Kevin Porter via NJD | F |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
2 | 32 | Ted Purcell via DET | F |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
2 | 39 | Drayson Bowman via CAR | F |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
2 | 42 | James Neal | F |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
2 | 44 | Niklas Hjalmarsson via PHI | D |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
4 | 76 | Matt Hunwick via DAL | D |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
4 | 85 | A.J. Thelen via OTT | D |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
5 | 108 | Eric Tangradi via EDM | F |
| NSHL8 | TOR |
5 | 119 | Theo Peckham via ANA | F |
| NSHL7 | TOR |
1 | 4 | Sam Gagner via VAN | F |
| NSHL7 | TOR |
1 | 6 | Thomas Hickey via CHI | D |
| NSHL7 | TOR |
1 | 9 | Angelo Esposito via DAL | F |
| NSHL7 | TOR |
1 | 13 | Brandon Sutter via EDM | F |
| NSHL7 | TOR |
2 | 25 | Michal Repik | F |
| NSHL7 | TOR |
3 | 72 | Drew Miller | F |
| NSHL7 | TOR |
5 | 120 | David Brown | G |
| NSHL6 | TOR |
1 | 23 | Ty Wishart | D |
| NSHL6 | TOR |
2 | 47 | Cody Franson | D |
| NSHL6 | TOR |
3 | 71 | Perttu Lindgren | F |
| NSHL6 | TOR |
4 | 96 | Niklas Grossman | D |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
1 | 1 | Sidney Crosby via CGY | F |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
1 | 14 | Brandon Bochenski via BOS | F |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
1 | 15 | Alexei Kaigorodov via MTL | F |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
2 | 33 | Nigel Dawes via SJS | F |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
2 | 47 | Jeremy Colliton | F |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
3 | 62 | Christoph Schubert via NSH | D |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
3 | 71 | Rejean Beauchemin | G |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
4 | 87 | Kyle Quincey via BOS | D |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
4 | 90 | Roman Kukumberg via COL | F |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
5 | 105 | Corey Locke via SJS | F |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
5 | 119 | Robert Earl | F |
| NSHL5 | TOR |
5 | 120 | Randy Jones via CHI | D |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
1 | 3 | Cam Barker via NYI | D |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
1 | 13 | Jakub Koreis via EDM | F |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
2 | 28 | Tim Brent via MIN | F |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
3 | 47 | Justin Peters via PHI | G |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
3 | 54 | Martin St.Pierre via CHI | F |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
3 | 56 | Rob Globke via BOS | F |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
4 | 66 | Richard Petiot via NYI | D |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
5 | 90 | Junior Lessard via DET | F |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
5 | 98 | Tuomas Pihlman via NSH | F |
| NSHL4 | TOR |
5 | 99 | Kirill Lyamin | D |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
1 | 2 | Marc-Andre Fleury via PHI | G |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
1 | 3 | Eric Staal via TBL | F |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
1 | 8 | Thomas Vanek via NSH | F |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
1 | 9 | Dion Phaneuf via OTT | D |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
2 | 29 | Donald Brashear via BOS | F |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
3 | 44 | Andre Roy via VAN | F |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
3 | 48 | Mark Messier via SJS | F |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
3 | 51 | Pasi Nurminen via MTL | G |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
3 | 60 | Georges Laraque | F |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
4 | 80 | Duvie Westcott | D |
| NSHL3 | TOR |
5 | 97 | Andy Chiodo | G |